Protesters drown out Sean Spicer at UMass
"This was childish, disrespectful, and embarrassing for UMass.”
November 28, 2018
AMHERST—For those looking for entertainment on Tuesday night, the University of Massachusetts Fine Arts Center did not disappoint. Sean Spicer, former press secretary for the Trump administration, discussed his career path and experience in the White House before a crowd of about 1,300 people.
On tour to promote his book, “The Briefing: Politics, The Press, and The President,” Spicer spoke for about an hour before answering questions audience members had written on note cards. A small section of the crowd erupted in protest at this point of the event, singing and chanting in opposition to Spicer and the administration he once represented.
Spicer opened the event by recalling his early life, focusing on the influence that his family had on his future career. Spicer noted that his family discussed public issues, rather than politics growing up in Rhode Island; they spoke often about the community and were simply the “kind of family growing up that had dinner around the table.”
Spicer and his parents worked hard to make ends meet. Education was important to him from a young age, Spicer said, and he recalled convincing his parents to let him apply to Portsmouth Abbey School, a competitive Roman-Catholic boarding school in Rhode Island. With the help of financial aid packages, Spicer’s family scraped by and paid the tuition.
His “awakening” to the world of government and politics came during his undergraduate studies at Connecticut College. Spicer’s government classes in school prompted him to consider different interpretations of the role of government, and he discovered his views leaned toward the right end of the political spectrum.
With his enthusiasm for politics fully ignited, Spicer started volunteering in local campaigns, gaining valuable experience with each election. In 2011, he became the communications director for the Republican National Committee, leading what he called the “new model” of electoral politics that led the GOP to crucial victories in 2014 and 2016.
He led an intensive grassroots movement, collecting data for over 190 million voters across the country through field teams — knocking on doors, making phone calls and engaging in local culture. This provided the Donald Trump campaign with data that increased their confidence, despite the mainstream reports and polling data.
“We can win…” Spicer told his team, “the numbers are there.”
Spicer’s loyalty to Trump and Republican politics earned him the position of White House Press Secretary following Trump’s victory. Having had “only 600 or so” on-camera opportunities beforehand, Spicer said he discussed the coming adjustment to fame with his family.
“My life changed in words I could never describe,” he said.
“We had a guy in New York with a Twitter account,” Spicer said of then-candidate Trump. “What could go wrong?”
The crowd erupted with laughter. Everything seemed to be going as planned for the former press secretary.
As Spicer transitioned to discuss his position at the White House, however, the crowd became rowdier.
“Did you lie?” One audience member asked.
Throughout the night, Spicer attempted to dismiss the small group of protesters who were determined to diminish his platform. This group persistently sang over Spicer as he tried to speak, reading off a sheet that appeared to have the lyrics to their song, “Solidarity Forever.”
Some members of the crowd booed the group, followed by applause when Spicer joked, “If you’re getting booed and I’m not, and we’re on a college campus, that’s saying something.”
— Kyle Moynihan (@kyle_moynihan_) November 28, 2018
Spicer, appearing unbothered by the protest, pretended to orchestrate the song with his microphone. Members of the group continued to stand up, unafraid to voice their opinions of the former press secretary and the Trump administration.
“Do you want to engage in a civil and respectful discussion, or just yell at me?” a clearly frustrated Spicer asked.
This hushed the crowd for a short period of time as the event moved into the Q&A segment.
The crowd erupted when Nick Consolini, UMass College Republicans president, announced that Spicer would answer preselected questions. “Take questions from the crowd!” one audience member shouted. Chants of “free speech” and a wave of booing rang throughout the Fine Arts Center.
— Kyle Moynihan (@kyle_moynihan_) November 28, 2018
At around 8 p.m., after Spicer had successfully answered three questions from Consolini, the event came to a close. Consolini later clarified in a statement that the College Republicans had no discretion over the Q&A format despite the frustrations in the crowd.
“This was by request of the school and the speaker,” Consolini said. “Due to the [Fine Art Center’s] layout a live Q&A logistically wouldn’t work out. Myself and the club were disappointed that weren’t able to do a live Q&A. Everyone in the audience had a chance to write a question in the lobby. We had a stack of over 40 questions, but due to a 10 minute disruption we were only able to make through very few of those.”
“Five people decided that they were more important than the hundreds of people who actually wanted to hear Mr. Spicer,” Consolini said. “I respect everyone’s free speech rights but they were interrupting someone else’s free speech and the ability of the audience to listen. This was childish, disrespectful and embarrassing for UMass.”
The College Republicans are no stranger to controversy and protest at their events. In April 2016, the RSO invited Steven Crowder, Milo Yiannopoulos, and Christina Hoff Sommers to campus to host a panel titled “The Triggering.” Similar protesters arrived in full force to the event, attempting to interrupt the discussion.
The UMass Graduate Employee Organization staged a protest outside the Student Union prior to Spicer’s talk.
Toward the end of the event, Spicer invited the group of protesters to the stage. Consolini applauded the action, but was unpleased with the end result.
“Spicer gave them the opportunity to come up and give a platform but they refused,” Consolini said. “This shows they were only there to disrupt and make a scene. I hope they learned something and became informed at the very least.”